Gibbons

Gibbons v. East Bay Regional Park District CA1/1

Good Law
Court of Appeal of CaliforniaJuly 9, 2025A168543ACalifornia4,615 words

Opinion

Opinion

Smiley, J.

I. BACKGROUND

Grant was “an avid and seasoned cyclist.” One morning in August 2020, he was cycling with his sister and a friend from Oakley to Concord and back, on a route he had “familiariz[ed] himself with” in advance “to ensure . . . public facilities” the group would “traverse were safe, accessible and regularly utilized by cyclists.” “[O]n the return leg of the trip, the group approached Ambrose Park.” “Proceeding along the sidewalk north of the park,” they reached a “wooden gate affixed with three metal signs.” The first “denoted the gate as an entrance to the Delta de Anza tr[ai]l, while the second sign listed . . . rules for trail users. The third and smallest sign read[]: ‘Warning Rough Trail.’ ” “After passing through the wooden gate, while proceeding in a normal and foreseeable fashion,” Grant’s “front tire entered and became wedged” in one “among a network of cracks or gaps in the [trail’s] surface, throwing him over the handlebars head-first onto the concrete surface.” He sustained a traumatic brain injury and lost consciousness. Grant passed away at a hospital 10 days later from resulting complications.

2 The cracks and gaps that caused this fatal accident “…

Sign in to read the full opinion

Create a free account to read the complete opinion text, citation history, and good-law status for this case.