Shin
Gabriel Shin v. Jeanine Nicholson, et al.
Opinion
Trial Court Opinion
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA 6 GABRIEL SHIN, Case No. 23-cv-00456-VC (DMR)
Plaintiff,
ORDER DENYING CCSF’S REQUEST
v. FOR RECONSIDERATION AND
DENYING AS MOOT PLAINTIFF’S
JEANINE NICHOLSON, et al., RESPONSIVE LETTER BRIEF Defendants. Re: Dkt. Nos. 201, 211
On November 24, 2025, Plaintiff Gabriel Shin filed a unilateral discovery letter seeking a court order compelling nonparty San Francisco Emergency Medical Services Agency (“EMSA”) to respond to Plaintiff’s Rule 45 document subpoena dated October 3, 2025. [Docket No. 184 (Pl. Ltr.); see Docket No. 184-1 at ECF pp.1–7 (EMSA subpoena).] The letter did not include the position of Defendants City and County of San Francisco (“CCSF”), Jeanine Nicholson, Robert Postel, Tom O’Connor, David Brown, Joe Certain, and Patricia Lee (collectively, the “CCSF Defendants”), though counsel for Plaintiff “attest[ed] to have attempted a live meet and confer with EMSA and CCSF.” Pl. Ltr. at 2…