Shin
Gabriel Shin v. Jeanine Nicholson, et al.
Opinion
Trial Court Opinion
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA 6 GABRIEL SHIN, Case No. 23-cv-00456-VC (DMR)
Plaintiff,
DISCOVERY ORDER
v. Re: Dkt. Nos. 224, 226 JEANINE NICHOLSON, et al., Defendants.
Plaintiff Gabriel Shin and Defendant City and County of San Francisco (“CCSF”) filed unilateral discovery letters regarding non-party San Francisco Emergency Medical Services Agency’s (“EMSA”) document production made in response to Plaintiff’s Rule 45 subpoena and the court’s December 9 and 22, 2025 Orders. [Docket No. 224 (Pl. Ltr.); Docket No. 226 (CCSF Ltr.); Docket No. 200 (Dec. 9 Order); Docket No. 212 (Dec. 22 Order).] Pursuant to Civil Local Rule 7-1(b), the court finds this matter suitable for disposition without oral argument. For the reasons set forth below, CCSF’s December 31, 2025 objections to the EMSA subpoena are stricken, and EMSA is ordered to produce all documents responsive to Plaintiff’s subpoena by January 15, 2026. I. BACKGROUND A detailed history of this…