Hernandez

Hernandez v. Chavez Roofing, Inc.

Good Law
1991 Cal. App. LEXIS 1268·235 Cal. App. 3d 1092·286 Cal. Rptr. 919·91 Daily Journal DAR 13488·56 Cal. Comp. Cases 650
Court of Appeal of CaliforniaOctober 31, 1991B054195California1,004 words

Opinion

Opinion

Gilbert, J.

— Here we hold that although an employee of an unlicensed and uninsured subcontractor is covered by a general contractor’s workers’ compensation insurance (Lab. Code, § 2750.5), the uninsured subcontractor may be liable in tort for injuries to the employee (§ 3706). We reverse the judgment of the trial court which was entered pursuant to the subcontractor’s motion for summary judgment.

Facts

On January 19,1989, Julian Hernandez was working for Chavez Roofing, Inc., (Chevy), when he was killed by being crushed between a fork lift and a truck owned and operated by Chavez. The accident occurred near a job site for which Chavez had a subcontract for roofing. Chavez had neither a current contractor’s license nor workers compensation insurance, but the general contractor, Braun and Associates, did.

Hernandez’s survivors brought a wrongful death action against Chavez and others. The original complaint alleged that Hernandez was an employee of Chavez, but the first amended complaint alleged that Hernandez was an independent contractor. Chavez moved for summary judgment on the ground that, as an employee of Chavez and Braun, Hernandez’s exclusive remedy was in Braun’s workers…

Sign in to read the full opinion

Create a free account to read the complete opinion text, citation history, and good-law status for this case.