Muelder

Muelder v. Western Greyhound Lines

Good Law

1970 Cal. App. LEXIS 2044·8 Cal. App. 3d 319·87 Cal. Rptr. 297

Court of Appeal of CaliforniaMay 28, 1970Civ. 9437California8,506 words

Opinion

Tamura, J.

Plaintiff sued to recover damages for the loss of a briefcase and its contents which defendant had undertaken to transport from Indio to San Bernardino. Following a nonjury trial the court found that the loss occurred through defendant’s gross negligence, assessed damages in the sum of $7,637.70 for the actual value of the briefcase and its contents, and entered judgment for plaintiff accordingly. Defendant appeals from the judgment.

Defendant’s sole contention is that under the applicable tariff schedule and sections 2200 and 2205 of the Civil Code, plaintiff’s recovery should have been limited to $50. The findings of gross negligence and the value of the lost items are unchallenged.

Plaintiff, a professor of education, attended a meeting at the Coachella Unified School District in his capacity as special consultant to the district. Upon his departure, he inadvertently left in the school district superintendent’s office a briefcase containing technical studies and reports, diaries, and miscellaneous correspondence. Plaintiff made arrangements with the superintendent to ship the briefcase to San Bernardino by defendant Greyhound Lines. The superintendent packaged the…

Sign in to read the full opinion

Create a free account to read the complete opinion text, citation history, and good-law status for this case.

Parties

WALLACE R. MUELDER
Plaintiff
WESTERN GREYHOUND LINES
Defendant

Judges

Tamura

Cites (63)

46 Cal. 2d 318
42 Cal. 227
13 Cal. 599
255 U.S. 317
112 U.S. 331
203 Cal. 680
55 Cal. App. 377
226 U.S. 491
17 F.2d 762
260 U.S. 584
227 U.S. 639
194 U.S. 427
233 U.S. 97
346 U.S. 128
374 F.2d 129
242 F.2d 598
228 U.S. 177
242 U.S. 148
29 Cal. 2d 782
28 Cal. 2d 347
151 Cal. 763
120 Cal. 156
34 Cal. App. 2d 475
60 Cal. 2d 92
159 Cal. 769
213 Cal. App. 2d 573
118 Cal. 683
14 Cal. App. 790
167 Cal. 112
131 Cal. 582
70 Cal. App. 2d 827
61 Cal. App. 2d 263
112 Cal. App. 150
44 Cal. 2d 191
68 Cal. App. 2d 725
81 Cal. App. 2d 437
66 Cal. 2d 963
241 Cal. App. 2d 115
84 U.S. 357
58 Cal. 2d 862
33 Cal. 2d 834
22 Cal. 2d 402
181 Va. 697
196 Miss. 367
52 Ga. App. 698
68 F. Supp. 877
143 Minn. 90
191 Mass. 27
82 N.J.L. 373
113 N.E. 814
197 So. 810
72 Ga. App. 309
75 Ohio App. 322
253 S.W.2d 959
2 Cal. 2d 384
262 Cal. App. 2d 824
262 Cal. App. 2d 222
257 Cal. App. 2d 71
79 Cal. App. 598
269 S.W.2d 855
135 F. Supp. 671
25 A.L.R. 2d 1337
414 Pa. 445