Schaefer

Schaefer v. California-Western States Life Insurance

Good Law
1968 Cal. App. LEXIS 2375·262 Cal. App. 2d 840·69 Cal. Rptr. 183
Court of Appeal of CaliforniaJune 11, 1968Civ. 31898California2,050 words

Opinion

Opinion

Fourt, J.

John M. Schaefer appeals the determination of the trial court that he did not properly receive a permanent waiver of life insurance policy premiums and that the issuer, California-Western States Life Insurance Company (hereinafter sometimes referred to as Cal-Western) is entitled to reformation of the policy on grounds of mutual mistake.

Appellant contends that the incontestability clause of the policy precludes Cal-Western from obtaining reformation on the ground of mutual mistake more than two years following the issuance of the policy; that the action for reformation is barred by the statute of limitations; and that the facts disclose only Cal-Western’s unilateral mistake which is not-sufficient grounds for reformation. These contentions are without merit.

The evidence discloses that in 1952 appellant's father, who had then been an agent for Cal-Western for almost 20 years, applied for and was issued a $5,000 “Junior Estate Builder” policy on the life of appellant, then about 14'years old. The policy provided for a $5,000 payment if the insured died prior to the policy anniversary date nearest his 21st birthday. If the insured survived that date, the insurance coveragé…

Sign in to read the full opinion

Create a free account to read the complete opinion text, citation history, and good-law status for this case.