Berry
Berry v. American Express Publishing, Inc.
Opinion
Opinion
Aronson, J.
Plaintiff Samuel A. Berry appeals a judgment dismissing the action entered after the trial court sustained without leave to amend demurrers to his complaint for injunctive relief based on the California Consumer Legal Remedies Act (CLRA), Civil Code section 1750 et seq. Berry contends he is entitled to seek injunctive relief under CLRA to enjoin enforcement of an allegedly unconscionable arbitration provision in agreements between cardholders and defendants American Express Travel-Related Services Company, Inc., American Express Centurion Bank, Inc. (AMEX Bank), and American Express Publishing, Inc. (AMEX Publishing) (collectively, AMEX).
Section 1770, subdivision (a), proscribes specified acts or practices “in a transaction intended to result or which results in the sale or lease of goods or services to any consumer . . . .” After considering CLRA’s text and legislative history, we conclude the extension of credit, such as issuing a credit card, separate and apart from the sale or lease of any specific goods or services, does not fall within the scope of the act. Accordingly, the trial court did not err in sustaining AMEX’s demurrer. Because Berry failed to demonstrate…