Rose
Rose v. Superior Court
Opinion
Opinion
GO Garcetti, District Attorney of Los Angeles County, George M. Palmer, Head Deputy District Attorney, Fred Macksoud and Roderick W. Leonard, Deputy District Attorneys, for Real Party in Interest.
The superior court did not comply with our order that it conduct a hearing on a petition for writ of habeas corpus. We therefore must grant a writ of mandate.
On February 3, 1996, Scott Riley and four friends met at a Long Beach bar to celebrate his birthday. During the course of the evening, they drank a considerable amount of alcohol. About 1:00 a.m., they were talking outside the bar when an African-American man and two women walked by. The two groups exchanged words.
Soon thereafter, several individuals confronted Riley's group. A man took a nine-millimeter pistol from his pocket and pointed it at Randy Borgfield. Borgfield turned and fled. More than a dozen shots were fired. Brian Borgfield, Randy's brother, was hit in the head by a nine-millimeter bullet and died. Two others were wounded.
The police conducted a photographic lineup. Three members of the Riley party identified petitioner Clarence Lasalle Rose as the assailant.