Guthrey

Guthrey v. State of California

Bad Law
1998 Cal. App. LEXIS 419·63 Cal. App. 2d 1108·63 Cal. App. 4th 1108·75 Cal. Rptr. 2d 27·98 Daily Journal DAR 4937
Court of Appeal of CaliforniaMay 11, 1998Docket Nos. F025848, F026374California6,209 words

Opinion

Opinion

Wiseman, J.

Anyone who has ever worked in an office or, for that matter, been a schoolchild on the playground knows that petty differences arise which cannot always be resolved without hurt feelings. Does that mean that these festering disputes in the workplace should find their way into the courts for resolution? Absolutely not. This case is a prime example of where such work-related differences have no place in the courtroom.

Raymond Guthrey obviously did not get along with his immediate supervisor, Loreen Lucas. Right or wrong, he was irritated by such things as having to keep his office door open and desk positioned so she could see him from her desk across the hall; for being reprimanded in front of his peers for taking a roundabout trip to a correctional camp which included a stop for gambling; for not receiving interest letters to promote when others received such letters in spite of the fact he was not on the certified list for a “limited term” position for which the letters were sent; and for not being able to put his feet on his desk and having to keep overhead lights turned on. These factors, and others, led him to believe he was being harassed and subjected to a hostile…

Sign in to read the full opinion

Create a free account to read the complete opinion text, citation history, and good-law status for this case.