Mosier
Mosier v. Southern California Physicians Ins. Exch.
Opinion
Opinion
Hastings, J.
The case presents a unique fact situation involving a courtesy defense provided to Dr. Neil Jouvenat, an uninsured physician, by appellant, Southern California Physicians Insurance Exchange (hereinafter SCPIE), which resulted in a jury verdict against SCPIE for fraud and conspiracy to breach fiduciary duty. Although the instant appeal involves only one plaintiff, one defendant and two counts, it is inextricably intertwined with two prior legal proceedings.
The first is the underlying medical malpractice action, brought by Ashley Hughes (Ashley), a quadriplegic, ventilator-dependent minor, and various family members, against Jouvenat and other defendants for debilitating medical injuries she suffered in their care during her delivery and the first few days of her life (hereinafter referred to as the personal injury action).
The second involves a bankruptcy petition filed by Jouvenat shortly after the verdict was rendered in.the personal injury action. Respondent Robert Mosier was appointed the interim bankruptcy trustee for Jouvenat’s estate.
The instant action was prosecuted by Mosier based upon allegations that SCPIE defrauded Jouvenat by inducing him to accept the…