Lucent Technologies, Inc. v. Gateway, Inc.

ORDER DENYING MOTIONS FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT OF INVALIDITY OF UNITED STATES PATENT NUMBERS 4,958,226; 4,383,272; 5,347,295; 4,763,356; 4,439,759

On November 30, 2007, defendants and counterclaimants Gateway, Inc. and related entities (“Gateway”), Microsoft Corp. (“Microsoft”), and Dell Inc. (“Dell” and collectively “Defendants”) brought various motions for summary judgment of invalidity with respect to United States Patent Numbers 4,958,226 (“Haskell '226”); 4,383,272 (“Netravali '272”); 5,347,295 (“Agulnick '295”); 4,763,356 (“Day '356”); and 4,439,759 (“Fleming '759”). (Doc. Nos. 66, 68-72, 83, 85.) More specifically, Gateway brought motions regarding the Haskell '226 and Fleming '759 patents. (Doc. Nos. 66, 70.) Dell brought motions regarding the Haskell '226, Netravali '272, Day '356, and Fleming '759 patents. (Doc. Nos. 68-69, 71-72.) Microsoft brought motions regarding the Day '356 and Agul-nick '295 patents. (Doc. Nos. 83, 85.) Gateway joined all of Dell’s and Microsoft’s motions. (Doc. Nos. 75, 86.) Dell joined all of Gateway’s and Microsoft’s motions. (Doc. Nos. 91-92.) Microsoft joined Dell’s and Gateway’s motions regarding the Haskell '226 and Day '356 patents. (Doc. No.…