Huang v. Young

256 F.2d 159 Ida HUANG, Appellant, v. Calvin J. I. YOUNG, administrator of the estate of Lun Cho Young, deceased, and Sandra H. N. Young and Sylvia H. I. Young, by their guardian, ad litem, Clinton R. Ashford, Appellees. No. 15874. United States Court of Appeals Ninth Circuit. June 9, 1958. N. W. Y. Char, Honolulu, Hawaii, William J. Gintjee, Jack P. Wong, San Francisco, Cal., for appellant. Fong, Miho & Chuck, Earl S. Robinson, Stephenson & Ashford, Clinton R. Ashford, Honolulu, Hawaii, Jack W. Sing, San Francisco, Cal., for appellees. Before HEALY, POPE and CHAMBERS, Circuit Judges. CHAMBERS, Circuit Judge. 1 Appellant as plaintiff in the district court on the basis of diversity of citizenship brought suit against the parties as named above. Calvin J. I. Young was also joined in his individual capacity. Other defendants were the decedent's wife, Claire C. Young and an adult son, Marvin J. G. Young. 2 Claims in the complaint were commingled together without separate statement. At the root of the controversy was the sum of $12,000 alleged to have been loaned by the plaintiff to Lun Cho Young in his lifetime and not repaid. The complaint on its face showed the regular form…