Samayoa

Samayoa v. Ayers

Good Law

649 F. Supp. 2d 1102·2009 WL 62424·2009 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 1417

United States District Court, Southern District of CaliforniaJanuary 9, 2009Civil 00cv2118-W (AJB)California29,202 words

Opinion

Whelan, J.

ORDER DENYING PETITIONER’S MOTION FOR EVIDENTIARY HEARING [Doc. No. 77]; DENYING PETITIONER’S MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT [Doc. No. 78]; DENYING THE PETITION

Petitioner Richard Gonzalez Samayoa has moved for an evidentiary hearing and/or summary judgment on several of the claims in his Amended Consolidated Petition for Writ of Habeas Corpus; Respondent Robert L. Ayers, Jr. opposes both motions.

Oral arguments were held before U.S. District Judge Thomas J. Whelan on December 11, 2008. Appointed counsel Glen Niemy appeared on behalf of Petitioner, and Deputy Attorney General Marilyn L. George of the California Attorney General’s Office appeared on behalf of Respondent. Upon consideration, the Court DENIES Petitioner’s motion for evidentiary hearing on Claims 1 and 4-10, DENIES Petitioner’s motion for summary judgment on Claims 1 and 6 and DENIES habeas relief as to all claims.

I. PROCEDURAL HISTORY

By an amended complaint filed February 21, 1986, Petitioner Richard Gonzales Samayoa was charged with the special circumstance murders of Nelia and Katherine Silva on December 18, 1985. He was also charged with the crime of burglary with a dangerous weapon. An Information alleging…

Sign in to read the full opinion

Create a free account to read the complete opinion text, citation history, and good-law status for this case.

Parties

Richard Gonzalez SAMAYOA
Plaintiff
Robert L. AYERS, Jr., Warden of the California State Prison at San Quentin
Defendant

Judges

Thomas J. Whelan

Cites (172)

15 Cal. 4th 795
501 U.S. 722
498 U.S. 411
463 U.S. 1032
Waltreus, supra,
41 Cal. 2d 756
34 Cal. 4th 193
5 Cal. 4th 813
18 Cal. 4th 770
5 Cal. 4th 750
17 Cal. 2d 734
96 F.3d 1126
673 F.2d 1031
244 F.3d 702
75 F.3d 562
321 F.3d 787
322 F.3d 573
9 F.3d 802
202 F.3d 1146
147 F.3d 1124
693 F.2d 859
521 U.S. 320
529 U.S. 362
376 F.3d 950
313 F.3d 1160
288 F.3d 1081
384 F.3d 628
403 F.3d 657
529 U.S. 420
431 F.3d 1158
372 U.S. 293
504 U.S. 1
1 Cal. 4th 1027
466 U.S. 668
23 Cal. 3d 412
Anderson, supra,
44 Cal. 3d 975
28 Cal. 3d 264
Freeman, supra,
177 Cal. App. 3d 958
46 Cal. 3d 1011
1 Cal. 4th 324
Wharton, supra,
43 Cal. 3d 739
Berryman, supra,
9 Cal. 4th 464
441 F.3d 638
550 U.S. 465
542 U.S. 649
397 F.3d 1236
18 F.3d 662
70 F.3d 1032
283 F.3d 1117
539 U.S. 510
316 F.3d 1079
350 U.S. 91
100 L. Ed. 83
268 F.3d 868
163 F.3d 1073
465 F.3d 1006
545 U.S. 374
59 F.3d 815
395 F.3d 979
494 U.S. 370
365 F.3d 706
279 F.3d 825
187 F.3d 1075
149 F.3d 923
974 F.2d 1099
236 F.3d 523
792 F.2d 846
469 U.S. 412
6 Cal. 4th 215
53 Cal. 3d 771
391 U.S. 510
448 U.S. 38
537 U.S. 322
4 Cal. 4th 929
4 Cal. 4th 742
399 U.S. 149
459 U.S. 4
404 U.S. 270
513 U.S. 364
474 U.S. 254
426 F.3d 1044
380 U.S. 400
541 U.S. 36
415 U.S. 308
390 U.S. 719
508 U.S. 333
506 U.S. 390
373 U.S. 83
473 U.S. 667
514 U.S. 419
540 U.S. 668
798 F.2d 1297
142 F.3d 1157
405 U.S. 150
604 F.2d 1245
431 U.S. 63
11 Cal. 3d 531
11 Cal. 4th 786
4 Cal. 4th 238
2 Cal. 4th 1148
538 U.S. 63
506 U.S. 20
354 F.3d 1101
366 F.3d 992
480 U.S. 39
282 F.3d 1204
475 U.S. 673
474 U.S. 15
507 U.S. 619
29 F.3d 1312
334 F.3d 803
508 U.S. 275
957 F.2d 1544
431 F.2d 688
98 F.3d 1102
52 F.3d 1465
500 U.S. 44
511 U.S. 79
428 U.S. 465
895 F.2d 610
477 U.S. 365
323 F.3d 1165
483 U.S. 44
422 U.S. 806
189 F.3d 1089
7 F.3d 174
53 Cal. 3d 618
408 F.3d 570
211 F.3d 480
897 F.2d 445
3 F.3d 1239
883 F.2d 750
928 F.2d 1470
509 U.S. 389
137 F.3d 1172
481 U.S. 129
518 U.S. 152
841 F.2d 881
297 F.3d 911
174 F.3d 1067
207 F.3d 557
21 F.3d 1446
94 F.3d 1321
798 F.2d 374
470 U.S. 298
499 U.S. 279
Sims, supra,
361 U.S. 199
474 U.S. 104
197 F.3d 1021
479 U.S. 157
412 U.S. 218
847 F.2d 1363
924 F.2d 813
93 F.3d 1434
517 U.S. 348
37 F.3d 504
362 U.S. 402
930 F.2d 714
420 U.S. 162
991 F.2d 524
769 F.2d 1341
505 U.S. 437
617 F.2d 180
384 F.3d 567
918 F.2d 1455
529 U.S. 473
223 F.3d 976