Lewis

People v. Lewis

Caution
13 Cal. 2d 280·1939 Cal. LEXIS 256·89 P.2d 388
Supreme Court of CaliforniaApril 10, 1939Crim. 4167California952 words

Opinion

Opinion

Seawell, J.

This appeal came to us on petition for hearing after decision by the District Court of Appeal, Second District, Division One. We adopt as a part of the opinion of this court the following portion of the opinion of the District Court of Appeal with respect to the questions that are involved on the appeal. It follows under quotation marks:

Conceding that the portion of said section 19a providing for a different punishment in counties where a penal farm is established is repugnant to the Constitution, on the ground that it is neither general in nature nor uniform in operation, and in addition is conditional and indefinite, and creates a different punishment for the same offense, it is apparent that the first sentence of said section 19a is severable from the second portion, and that the second portion is not involved so far as county jail imprisonment is concerned, for the reason that the appellant was not committed under the invalid portion of said act. The plain unambiguous language and meaning of the first sentence is not affected by the invalidity which inheres in the second portion.

The first portion of section 19a, which provides that “in no case shall any person sentenced to…

Sign in to read the full opinion

Create a free account to read the complete opinion text, citation history, and good-law status for this case.