Save Our Heritage Organisation v. County of San Diego CA4/1
Opinion
Opinion
Irion, J.
I.
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
A. The Project
The EIR analyzes a proposed mixed-use development, referred to as the "Cedar
and Kettner Development Project" (the Project), on County-owned property in downtown
San Diego. The property is bounded on the north by Cedar Street, on the east by Kettner
Boulevard, on the south by Beech Street, and on the west by railroad and trolley rights-
of-way. As of June 2012, the parcel contained a parking lot over the northern two-thirds
of the project site, and the southern one-third contained two structures, the three-story
Star Builders Supply Company office building (Star Building) and a warehouse.
The Star Building is a city-designated historical structure. It was built in 1911 to
serve as a warehouse to store goods delivered via the railroad line at the west edge of the
Project site. An oil company occupied the site from 1948 to 1973, during which time
petroleum hydrocarbons contaminated the site. The greatest concentrations of
Subsequent undesignated section references are to the Public Resources Code.
2 contaminants were found in the southwest portion of the Project site, including directly
under the Star…