Rev Op Group v. ML Manager LLC (In Re Mortgages Ltd.)

Mortgages Ltd. was a private lender for certain real estate investments in Arizona. Mortgages Ltd. raised money from investors to extend loans to real estate purchasers, secured by the purchased real estate, and acted as servicing agent for the loans and properties. The investors received “pass-through” fractional interests in the real estate that secured the loans and the resulting loan payments. The pass-through investors acquired an actual interest in each underlying loan.

On June 24, 2008, Mortgages Ltd. filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy. The company was restructured through a confirmed bankruptcy plan. Pursuant to that plan, the entity ML Manager LLC (ML Manager), the appellee here, manages and oper ates' the loans left in Mortgages Ltd.’s portfolio. ML Manager took a $20 million loan in “exit financing” to pay for expenses related to the completed bankruptcy. The bankruptcy plan was confirmed by the bankruptcy court in May 2009.

After confirmation, ML Manager sought to sell some of the loans in Mortgages Ltd.’s portfolio. In response, a group of pass-through investors (Rev Op Group) objected to the sales. Rev Op Group and ML Manager then moved, essentially, for…