Uriell
Uriell v. Regents of UC
Opinion
Opinion
INTRODUCTION
A jury found the University of California San Diego Medical Center (UCSD) failed
to timely diagnose Barbara Kastan's breast cancer in 2007 resulting in her death in 2010.
The Regents of the University of California (Regents)1 appeal the wrongful death
judgment in favor of Kastan's husband and children contending: (1) plaintiffs' expert
lacked foundation for his opinion there was a reasonable medical probability Kastan
would have survived 10 more years if she had been timely diagnosed and (2) the court
failed to properly instruct the jury on the issue of causation when it gave the standard
substantial factor jury instruction rather than a special instruction regarding proof of
causation to "a reasonable medical probability." We disagree with both contentions and
affirm the judgment.
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
A
Kastan had an extensive family history of breast cancer. Her mother was
diagnosed with breast cancer in her early 50s and died at age 68 or 69, approximately
years after she was diagnosed. Kastan's mother's aunt died of breast cancer. In addition,