United States v. Honorable Manuel L. Real, United States District Judge

The Government seeks a writ of mandamus compelling the district court to set aside its order of November 16, 1970, dismissing the indictment against Eck, the real party in interest, and directing the district court to sentence Eck on his plea of guilty.

Eck was indicted for a violation of 18 U.S.C. § 659 (theft from an interstate shipment). With the United States Attorney’s consent, Eck pleaded guilty to the lesser-included offense of stealing goods valued at less than $100. On November 10, 1969, the district court ordered the sentencing continued for one year for the purpose of Eck’s demonstrating to the court that he could lead a law-abiding life. When Eck returned a year later, the court was satisfied with Eck’s behavior, and it requested the United States Attorney to dismiss the indictment. The request was refused. The district court thereupon dismissed the indictment in the interest of justice, and this petition followed.

The district court’s merciful inclinations appear entirely appropriate in view of the nature of the offense, of Eck’s youth, his lack of any prior criminal record, and his good conduct during the rehabilitative year. However, we are unable to find any…