United Steelworkers v. Retirement Income Plan for Hourly-Rated Employees of Asarco, Inc.

FOR PUBLICATION

UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS

FOR THE NINTH CIRCUIT

UNITED STEELWORKERS OF AMERICA; 

ALBERTO AGUILAR, JR.; ANGEL L.

ARELLANO; JESUS M. CANABA;

FRANCISCO CARREON; FRANKLIN

DAVILA; JAIME O. FRAUSTO;

ARMANDO B. HIDALGO; SANTIAGO

MARTINEZ; HECTOR OCHOA; ISMAEL

ORTEGA; MAURICIO ORTEGA;

LORENZO RAMIREZ; SERGIO

RAMIREZ; ERNESTO ROBLES; CARLOS No. 05-16833

RODRIGUEZ; ROBERTO ROMO;

RAMON SANCHEZ; ARTURO R.

 D.C. No.

CV-04-00010-

SAUCEDO; UNITED STEELWORKERS OF DCB/JJM

AMERICA, AFL-CIO, CLC; JESUS

M. URANGA; RUBEN R. VILLARREAL,

Plaintiffs-Appellees, v.

RETIREMENT INCOME PLAN FOR

HOURLY-RATED EMPLOYEES OF

ASARCO, INC.; ASARCO, INC.,

Defendants-Appellants. 

121 122 UNITED STEELWORKERS v. RETIREMENT INCOME PLAN

ALBERTO AGUILAR, JR.; ANGEL L. 

ARELLANO; JESUS M. CANABA;

FRANCISCO CARREON; FRANKLIN

DAVILA; JAIME O. FRAUSTO;

ARMANDO B. HIDALGO; SANTIAGO

MARTINEZ; HECTOR OCHOA; ISMAEL

ORTEGA; MAURICIO ORTEGA;

LORENZO RAMIREZ; SERGIO

RAMIREZ; ERNESTO ROBLES; CARLOS

RODRIGUEZ; ROBERTO ROMO;

RAMON SANCHEZ; ARTURO R. No. 06-15862

 SAUCEDO; UNITED STEELWORKERS OF D.C.…