Gartler

Gartler v. First Nat. Bk. of San Pedro

Good Law
1928 Cal. App. LEXIS 331·88 Cal. App. 411·263 P. 566
Court of Appeal of CaliforniaJanuary 19, 1928Docket No. 4568.California1,273 words

Opinion

Lead Opinion

Stephens, J.

On August 23, 1919, George Gartler, one of the plaintiffs, paid $501.50 to defendant bank at San Pedro for a draft in favor of H. Gartler, the other plaintiff, calling for 6,250 lei, Roumanian money, from the "Banca Moldova" in the city of Jasi, Roumania. The draft was presented to the drawee bank on September 15, November 8, and December 15, and 19, 1919, but each time payment was refused. Later 1-I. Gartler, the payee, having meanwhile removed to San Pedro, together with George Gartler, the purchaser of the draft, brought suit against defendant bank for $501.50 as damages, with legal interest and costs, alleging that since presentation 6,250 id "have become of little or no value in dollars." Defendant submitted a demurrer upon the ground that no cause of action had been stated. Defendant also demurred for uncertainty on many grounds, among them the following: That it cannot be ascertained from the complaint whether or not protest had been made after presentation of the draft; why p~yment was refused; what act or omission is chargeable to defendants; whether plaintiffs are suing for rescission or for damages from breach of contract; or what date value of the lei is to be taken in…

Sign in to read the full opinion

Create a free account to read the complete opinion text, citation history, and good-law status for this case.