Butters

Butters v. the Brawley Star

Good Law
1920 Cal. App. LEXIS 384·48 Cal. App. 57·291 P. 987
Court of Appeal of CaliforniaJune 3, 1920Civ. No. 2484.California3,265 words

Opinion

Lead Opinion

Thomas, J.

By this action plaintiff seeks specific performance of an agreement to deliver a certain Overland automobile, or the payment of the sum of $795, the value thereof, if delivery cannot be made, and general relief.

From the record we gather that defendants were the publishers of a newspaper called the “Brawley Star,” at Brawley, Imperial County; that during a certain period— from May 13, 1916, to June 24, 1916, both dates inclusive— they conducted what is commonly known as a newspaper subscription contest, for the purpose of securing paid subscriptions for said newspaper; that as an inducement for candidates to obtain such subscriptions they offered as “first prize” a certain Overland automobile, the value of which, it is alleged, was $795, and for which plaintiff Anna D. Butters was one of the contestants; that for each paid subscription secured by any of the candidates a certain number of votes was credited to the contestant securing the same, or to whose credit a subscriber making a voluntary subscription might direct; and that at the end of sueh contest one Frances Blake, also a contestant, was declared to have received the largest number of votes, and was therefore claimed to…

Sign in to read the full opinion

Create a free account to read the complete opinion text, citation history, and good-law status for this case.