Fox

Commercial Acetylene Supply Co. v. Fox

Good Law
47 Cal. App. 673·191 P. 33
Court of Appeal of CaliforniaMay 22, 1920Civ. No. 3221.California564 words

Opinion

Lead Opinion

Nourse, J.

Judgment in the sum of $400 was rendered in favor of plaintiff and against defendant in this action, from which the latter appeals.

The action (which was tried on an agreed statement of facts) was for damage to four gas cylinders, of the value of $440, owned by plaintiff, and which were almost totally destroyed by fire while in the possession of defendant, without negligence on his part. Their value, when subsequently returned to the plaintiff, was but forty dollars. The cylinders contained acetylene gas sold by plaintiff to defendant upon a contract in the form of a letter addressed by plaintiff to defendant and accepted by the latter. It provided as follows:

The determination of this action resolves itself into a proper interpretation of the foregoing agreement. It is conceded that a bailee may by a special contract assume the liability of an insurer. The question here is whether this agreement met the requirements necessary for such a contract so as to make the bailee liable for damages occurring without his negligence.

Appellant argues that it enlarged his liability only in that it increased the degree of care to be exercised by him; that otherwise it merely expressed what…

Sign in to read the full opinion

Create a free account to read the complete opinion text, citation history, and good-law status for this case.