J. I. Case Threshing Co. v. Copren Bros.

Good Law
1917 Cal. App. LEXIS 392·35 Cal. App. 70·169 P. 443
Court of Appeal of CaliforniaOctober 22, 1917Civ. No. 1697.California3,257 words

Opinion

Lead Opinion

Chipman, J.

Appeal from an order to change the place of trial from Sierra County to Plumas County on motion of plaintiff made on the ground that an impartial trial cannot be had in Sierra County. The action was to recover judgment upon certain promissory notes executed by the defendants for the purchase price of a certain traction engine, and was begun in the city and county of San Francisco, but the venue was changed to Sierra County, on the ground that all the defendants resided therein.

The cause was tried before a jury in Sierra County and a verdict directed by the court was rendered in favor of plaintiff. An appeal was taken to this court which resulted in a reversal of the judgment. The remittitur went down in January, 1917, and on April 18, 1917, the court made its order from which this appeal was taken. As yet the cause had not been set for trial and, of course, no attempt had been made to obtain a jury. The motion was heard upon the affidavit of Jesse J. Dunn, attorney for plaintiff, and “upon the papers and files in the case” and upon the affidavits in rebuttal of John V. Copren, attorney for defendants, and 'Win. J. Copren, one of the defendants in the action.

By the affidavit of…

Sign in to read the full opinion

Create a free account to read the complete opinion text, citation history, and good-law status for this case.