Swain

Swain v. Kleiber Co., Inc.

Caution
1918 Cal. App. LEXIS 43·39 Cal. App. 341·178 P. 728
Court of Appeal of CaliforniaDecember 31, 1918Civ. No. 2507.California1,688 words

Opinion

Lead Opinion

Sturtevant, J.

Plaintiff, an automobile salesman, sued defendant, a manufacturer of auto trucks, for commissions claimed to be due him under his contract of employment with the defendant. The cause was tried before a jury, and resulted in a verdict for the plaintiff for part of the amount demanded. A motion for a new trial made by the defendant company being denied, it appeals from the judgment, and contends in support of its appeal that the evidence is wholly insufficient to justify the verdict, and that the court erred in several particulars in its instructions to the jury.

The contract of employment was oral, and the parties are not agreed as to its precise terms. According to the defendant the contract was the ordinary one between a salesman on commission and his employer, by which the salesman is entitled to commission only upon orders obtained by him. If the jury had accepted this version of the contract its verdict would have been in favor of the defendant; and we must regard their verdict in plaintiff’s favor as indicating that they accepted his version of the agreement, and held that the parties entered into a much more liberal arrangement than the one contended for by the defendant.…

Sign in to read the full opinion

Create a free account to read the complete opinion text, citation history, and good-law status for this case.