Minehan

Minehan v. Silveria

Good Law
131 Cal. App. 317·1933 Cal. App. LEXIS 750·21 P.2d 617
Court of Appeal of CaliforniaApril 21, 1933Docket No. 8803.California891 words

Opinion

Lead Opinion

Gray, J.

The record, on this appeal, consists of the judgment-roll. The complaint alleges that three defendants, named therein, to wit, a copartnership and its two partners were indebted to plaintiffs in the sum-of $1993.45 for goods sold and delivered. The three defendants filed a joint general demurrer, of which no disposition is shown. Subsequently the two copartners answered, in two inconsistent counts, denying any indebtedness and admitting an indebtedness of $344. The court found “that defendants are indebted to plaintiffs in the sum of $343.55, . . . That defendants have heretofore tendered said sum of $343.55 into court,” and concluded “that plaintiffs are entitled to a judgment against said defendants in the sum of $343'.55 without costs and that defendants are entitled to their costs herein”. The judgment adjudged “that plaintiffs do have and recover from defendants the sum of $343.55, without costs, said sum having been paid into court” and “that defendants are entitled to their costs”.

Assuming that the judgment against “defendants” included all defendants, plaintiffs argue that, as the' answer of the copartners abandoned the joint demurrer and the co-partnership defaulted by…

Sign in to read the full opinion

Create a free account to read the complete opinion text, citation history, and good-law status for this case.