Robinson

Butler v. Robinson

Good Law
1926 Cal. App. LEXIS 402·76 Cal. App. 223·244 P. 162
Court of Appeal of CaliforniaJanuary 15, 1926Docket No. 4534.California1,173 words

Opinion

Lead Opinion

Craig, J.

The plaintiff brought an action in the superior court of this state against the appellant as executor of the estate of Ida Thomas, deceased, in which it was alleged, among other things, that “during the lifetime of the deceased the plaintiff rendered personal service to her and furnished her with board, room to live in, and with divers and sundry articles of medicine, all of the reasonable value of $2,035.20,” and “that during the lifetime of Ida Thomas, deceased, became indebted to the plaintiff for her care, room rent and attention,” in said sum. The complaint also contained an allegation that the deceased had promised to pay for the said board, room, and personal services. Thereafter the executor served and filed a motion “To require the plaintiff to set forth in her complaint the various dates when she claims that she rendered the personal service to the deceased during her lifetime, or that she furnish a bill of particulars of each of such items, or that she file an amended complaint, and attach to the complaint, by way of exhibit, a true copy of the claims which it is alleged therein, she caused to be filed with the said executor, and that if more than one claim was filed…

Sign in to read the full opinion

Create a free account to read the complete opinion text, citation history, and good-law status for this case.