Meserve

Imperial Water Co. No. 4 v. Meserve

Good Law
1923 Cal. App. LEXIS 414·62 Cal. App. 593·217 P. 548
Court of Appeal of CaliforniaJune 19, 1923Civ. No. 3810.California3,573 words

Opinion

Lead Opinion

Finlayson, J.

Plaintiff, a mutual water company incorporated under the laws of this state, brings this action against Lizzie H. Meserve and her two sons, Edwin A. Meserve and Harry W. Meserve, to recover the sum of $681.28 alleged to be due for “water sold and delivered” to defendants. Judgment for that sum was rendered against the three defendants, two of whom, Edwin A. and Harry W. Meserve, have taken this appeal.

In a complaint consisting of three counts plaintiff alleges : In the first count, that defendants “purchased from plaintiff” and the latter “sold and delivered to defendants,” for agricultural purposes, water to the amount and value of $681.28, which defendants promised to pay; in the second count, that the water was reasonably worth $681.28; and in the third, that the defendants are “indebted” to plaintiff in the sum of $681.28 for water so sold and delivered. Edwin A. Meserve and his mother joined in an answer wherein they deny practically all of the allegations of the complaint. Harry W. Meserve answered separately. Like his codefendants, he also denied substantially every allegation of the complaint. As a fur ther answer Harry W. Meserve alleged that the plaintiff is a mutual…

Sign in to read the full opinion

Create a free account to read the complete opinion text, citation history, and good-law status for this case.