Hartje

Hartje v. Olcott

Good Law
116 Cal. App. 712·1931 Cal. App. LEXIS 418·3 P.2d 340
Court of Appeal of CaliforniaSeptember 21, 1931Docket No. 7624.California350 words

Opinion

Lead Opinion

Knight, J.

The trial court sitting without a jury awarded plaintiff $600 damages on account of personal injuries suffered by him while riding as a passenger for hire in an automobile operated by defendant as a “jitney bus”, and defendant appeals, contending that the evidence is insufficient to sustain the trial court’s findings upon the issues of negligence and contributory negligence.

It appears from the evidence without dispute that upon entering the tonneau of the automobile (a seven-passenger sedan), plaintiff took hold of the handle on the inside of the door to close it, and while he was still in a standing, bent-over position, about to close the door and sit down in one of the “jump” seats, defendant started ahead with a jerk and at a rapid rate of speed, throwing plaintiff off balance and causing the door to slam violently on his thumb, inflicting severe and painful injuries thereto, which placed him under the care of a surgeon and incapacitated him from work for some six weeks.

In our opinion the foregoing facts are amply sufficient to sustain the trial court’s findings on the issues above mentioned. Defendant argues that the only inference to be drawn from the evidence is that…

Sign in to read the full opinion

Create a free account to read the complete opinion text, citation history, and good-law status for this case.