Servais

Servais v. Klein

Good Law
112 Cal. App. 26·1931 Cal. App. LEXIS 1017·296 P. 123
Court of Appeal of CaliforniaFebruary 17, 1931Docket No. 6464.California3,876 words

Opinion

Lead Opinion

Works, J.

This is an action for unlawful detainer, arising upon the terms of a written lease. The instrument was entered into between plaintiffs as lessors and the defendants Klein and Weiss as lessees, but the latter assigned their interest under it to Thomas B. Key, formerly a defendant in the action, and the present defendant Nellie Key. Pending proceedings in the trial court Thomas B. Key died and defendant Fraser as administrator of his estate was substituted in his place. Judgment went against Fraser as administrator and Nellie Key. They appeal.

The principal point in the case is that which requires the construction of a certain paragraph of the lease, which reads:

The question concerning the paragraph is presented under these circumstances: Appellants contend that a certain portion of it is void as providing for a forfeiture. The trial judge adopted the contrary view and made findings and rendered judgment accordingly.

Before taking up the authorities upon which the parties respectively rely for a solution of the question presented, it becomes necessary to make some analysis of the paragraph of the lease from which the controversy between them springs. It is provided therein,…

Sign in to read the full opinion

Create a free account to read the complete opinion text, citation history, and good-law status for this case.