Symons

Symons v. Wooden

Good Law
1929 Cal. App. LEXIS 676·97 Cal. App. 39·274 P. 987
Court of Appeal of CaliforniaFebruary 19, 1929Docket No. 3590.California633 words

Opinion

lead Opinion

Finch, J.

The complaint alleges damages sustained in an automobile collision caused by the negligence of the defendants as follows: damage to plaintiffs’ automobile, $573.15; loss of use of the automobile for 16 days, $80, and damage to a tire and tube, $20.85. Verdict and judgment went for the plaintiffs for the total amount demanded and the defendants have appealed.

In his opening statement to the jury counsel for the plaintiffs stated that at a time subsequent to the collision the plaintiffs informed defendant Hanby of the amount of the damage to their automobile and that Hanby replied: “Don’t pay any of the damages, we are carrying insurance, we are fully protected, don’t pay the repair bill, present your bill to the surety company, it will be paid.” Evidence to the same effect was introduced. Defendants made no objection to the opening statement or to the evidence referred to when it was offered. Objection was first made when counsel for the plaintiffs commented on such evidence in his argument to the jury. The court instructed the jury “that you are not concerned with the matter or fact of whether the defendants did or did not carry liability insurance, . . . and it is your duty to…

Sign in to read the full opinion

Create a free account to read the complete opinion text, citation history, and good-law status for this case.