Mickschl

Mickschl v. National Council of Knights & Ladies of Security

Good Law
1919 Cal. App. LEXIS 80·40 Cal. App. 100·180 P. 27
Court of Appeal of CaliforniaFebruary 27, 1919Civ. No. 2311.California561 words

Opinion

Lead Opinion

Shaw, J.

Plaintiff, as beneficiary therein, sought to recover upon an insurance policy issued by defendant to Norma Grace Mickschl. The answer alleged a breach of warranty on the part of the insured in that she falsely represented that the death of her mother, Mrs. Gould, was due to an attack of pneumonia, whereas, in fact, her death was due to pulmonary tuberculosis. Judgment went for plaintiff, from which defendant appealed.

Appellant’s sole contention, in which there is no merit, is that the finding of the court to the effect that the death of Mrs. Gould, the mother of the insured, was caused by an attack of pneumonia, as represented by her, and not from pulmonary tuberculosis, as alleged by the defendant, is not supported by the evidence.

[1] The burden of affirmatively proving the falsity of the representation made by the insured, and upon which the policy was issued, devolved upon defendant (Code Civ. Proc., sec. 1981 ; Penn Mutual L. Ins. Co. v. Mechanics’ Sav. Bank, 38 L. R. A. 33-69, note), which called Dr. Strong as the only witness, who testified touching the cause of Mrs. Gould’s death. Referring to the certificate of death prepared by the witness and wherein the cause of…

Sign in to read the full opinion

Create a free account to read the complete opinion text, citation history, and good-law status for this case.