Morris
Morris v. Bekin's Van and Storage Co.
Opinion
Lead Opinion
Kerrigan, J.
This is an action brought to recover the value of certain personal property alleged to have been lost by reason of the negligence of the defendant as a common carrier. After a trial by the court sitting without a jury a judgment was entered in favor of plaintiffs. This appeal is from the judgment upon the judgment-roll alone.
1. The complaint shows that the appellant received the goods in question April 16, 1906, and agreed to transport them from San Francisco to Oakland. The trial court found that the time agreed upon for the delivery of the goods was April 16, 1907. The cause was tried March 30, 1907, seventeen days prior to the date upon which it is found that appellant was to deliver the goods. Appellant contends tMt, according to this finding, it was not in default either at the commencement of the action or at the time of the trial, and that consequently the judgment against it is unauthorized. The complaint was filed July 25, 1906; the cause was tried November 26, 1906, and judgment was entered April 9, 1907. There is no claim that the action was prematurely brought, nor is there anything in the record which supports the finding that the property was to be delivered in…