Mora
Mora v. Favilla
Opinion
Lead Opinion
Beasly, J.
The plaintiff was injured by slip- . ping and falling on a steep sidewalk in the city of San Francisco. The sidewalk had been wetted by being washed by the defendant at 10 o ’clock on the morning of the accident, and it was claimed that the wet and slippery condition of the sidewalk caused the plaintiff to fall. By washing the sidewalk at that hour defendant violated an ordinance of the city and county which made it unlawful to wash a sidewalk between 8 A. M. and 6 P. M. The defenses were the legal contention that the ordinance was not designed for the protection of pedestrians on a sidewalk, but that its purpose was to conserve the water supply of the city, and hence, that it did not constitute negligence between the parties' here for the defendant to wash the sidewalk in violation of the ordinance; and, second, the allegation as a fact in the answer that the plaintiff was intoxicated when the accident occurred, and that this either caused or contributed to his fall. The jury found for the defendant. The plaintiff moved for a new trial on the grounds of insufficiency of the evidence to justify the verdict ; that it was against law; and of errors occurring at the trial. The court…