Drenth
Globe Grain & Milling Co. v. Drenth
Opinion
Lead Opinion
Kerrigan, J.
This action was brought by plaintiff for the alleged conversion of certain grain. The trial was had before a jury, and at the conclusion of the plaintiff’s case a motion of nonsuit was made, and the court took the case from the jury and granted the motion, and this is an appeal from the judgment of nonsuit.
There are two points relied upon for a reversal, (1st) that no proper motion for a nonsuit was made; and (2d) that there was sufficient evidence to make out a prima facie case for the jury.
The first objection is based upon the assertion that no formal motion for nonsuit was ever made, and if made, the grounds of the motion were not specified.
The record clearly discloses the fact that not only was the motion made, but that it was based and granted upon the grounds that there had been no sufficient change of possession of the property under a sale thereof to satisfy the requirements of section 3440 of the Civil Code, and further, that it was not shown that there was ever any sale of the property. There is, therefore, no merit in either of the contentions contained in the first objection.
In support of the second objection it is argued that plaintiff presented substantial…