Vawter

Vawter v. Purdy

Good Law
1916 Cal. App. LEXIS 168·29 Cal. App. 623·157 P. 556
Court of Appeal of CaliforniaFebruary 9, 1916Civ. No. 1728.California1,373 words

Opinion

Lead Opinion

James, J.

Plaintiff the widow of E. J. Vawter, brought this action against defendants Purdy and Flint as trustees of a benefit fund which had been provided by an association of the nature of a fraternal organization. Upon the death of plaintiff’s husband claim was made’against the trustees for the sum of $758, to which it was alleged the plaintiff was entitled. Defendant Bassett claimed to be entitled to the same money by reason of having been substituted by the deceased Yawter in place of the original beneficiary, the plaintiff. Defendants Purdy and Flint answered, affirming that Yawter had requested them, as trustees, to pay the benefit fund to defendant Bassett, and averring that they were mere stakeholders, and held the money and would continue to hold the same to be paid pursuant to the judgment of the court. The findings of the court were against the plaintiff, and an affirmative judgment was entered in favor of the defendant Bassett as against the trustees mentioned. The appeal is taken from that judgment. This being an action at law, and the fund not being in court and physically subject to judicial disposition, we are at a loss to see by what authority an affirmative judgment was…

Sign in to read the full opinion

Create a free account to read the complete opinion text, citation history, and good-law status for this case.