Cyty

People v. Cyty

Good Law
11 Cal. App. 702·1909 Cal. App. LEXIS 87·106 P. 257
Court of Appeal of CaliforniaNovember 12, 1909Crim. No. 134.California3,453 words

Opinion

lead Opinion

Taggart, J.

Appellant was informed against for the crime of murder, found guilty of manslaughter, and sentenced to imprisonment in the state prison for ten years.

It is contended in support of this appeal from the judgment and the order denying defendant a new trial that the evidence does not sustain the verdict, because the facts either establish murder or exonerate the defendant from the commission of any offense whatever; that the court erred in its rulings upon the admission and rejection of certain evidence specified; and that it also erred in giving certain instructions defining and relating to manslaughter and in relation to what acts upon the part of an assailant justify the taking of his life; also, that the court erred in refusing to give an instruction, requested by defendant, which declared the law relating to the right of a person assailed to stand his ground instead of retreating to avoid a conflict.

Appellant and the deceased, C. Kyle Smith, were miners and prospectors in Inyo county, between whom there had been disputes as to their respective rights in the mining claim upon which the defendant was working at the time of the killing, and as to the right of possession of…

Sign in to read the full opinion

Create a free account to read the complete opinion text, citation history, and good-law status for this case.