Mountain

Mountain v. Industrial Accident Commission

Good Law
1928 Cal. App. LEXIS 781·92 Cal. App. 176·267 P. 913
Court of Appeal of CaliforniaMay 23, 1928Docket No. 5927.California407 words

Opinion

lead Opinion

Houser, J.

By this proceeding petitioner seeks the annulment of an order made by the respondent Industrial Accident Commission by which petitioner was denied compensation for an injury sustained by him, alleged to have arisen out of and in the course of his employment.

The evidence adduced at the hearing of the application for compensation in substance was that in the course of petitioner’s employment he was sent in an automobile on an errand of getting a suitcase for his employer; that after procuring the suitcase, instead of returning in a direct course to the appointed place of the delivery thereof, petitioner deviated from such course by going seven blocks in an opposite direction for the purpose of obtaining a package of cigarettes for his own satisfaction and enjoyment. On his way back from such deviation, but nevertheless at a point at least four blocks outside of any direct or reasonable course from the place the suitcase was obtained, to the place of its intended destination, the accident occurred for which petitioner claimed compensation.

Much has been written and great learning displayed by various courts and textwriters concerning the legal questions affecting a situation such…

Sign in to read the full opinion

Create a free account to read the complete opinion text, citation history, and good-law status for this case.