Livermore

Livermore v. Ratti

Good Law
150 Cal. 458·1907 Cal. LEXIS 538·89 P. 327
Supreme Court of CaliforniaFebruary 7, 1907S.F. No. 3546.California2,832 words

Opinion

Lead Opinion

In the petition for rehearing it was urged that the recital in the order settling the final account of the guardian, that "proof was made to the satisfaction of the court that notice of said settlement had been given as required *Page 460 by law, and as ordered by the court," is, upon this inquiry, which in effect is collateral, conclusive evidence that the representative of the deceased ward's estate had, in some manner, received due and legal notice of the time and place of the hearing of the account; that it conclusively established jurisdiction; and that we cannot look into the record to ascertain what notice was in fact given to him, or receive proof of other facts outside the record to show the lack of jurisdiction. The rehearing was granted chiefly for the purpose of re-examining this point. Upon further consideration we are satisfied that the proposition is untenable. The proper solution of the question depends upon the applicability of section 1634 of the Code of Civil Procedure to the proceedings for the settlement of the final account of a guardian. That it does apply thereto has not been disputed by either party. Section 1789 of the Code of Civil Procedure provides…

Addendum

This is an appeal by the defendants from the judgment and from an order denying their motion for a new trial. The complaint sets forth an action to enforce a lien against certain lands formerly belonging to the deceased Delfina L. Ratti, the said Giovanni being her sole surviving heir at law. Teresa B. Livermore was the mother of the deceased Delfina L. Ratti. In April, 1888, she was appointed guardian of the person and estate of Delfina, and continued to act in that capacity until the said Delfina arrived at the age of eighteen years, which was on the 25th of November, 1892. No account of her trust as guardian was ever filed or presented to the court during the minority of the ward, nor at all until March 15, 1899. On September 29, 1897, the ward, Delfina, was married to the defendant, Giovanni B. Ratti, and on September 19, 1898, she died intestate, leaving surviving her husband and one child, which child has since died at the age of four months. On March 15, 1899, when the guardian, Teresa B. Livermore, filed her final account as guardian of her daughter, Delfina, there had been no administrator appointed of the estate of her said daughter, although proceedings to that effect…

Sign in to read the full opinion

Create a free account to read the complete opinion text, citation history, and good-law status for this case.