Coit

Coit v. Western Union Telegraph Co.

Caution
130 Cal. 657·1900 Cal. LEXIS 907·63 P. 83
Supreme Court of CaliforniaDecember 14, 1900S.F. No. 1521.California2,704 words

Opinion

Lead Opinion

Garoutte, J.

Plaintiffs telegraphed to W. B. Dennis, at St. Louis, asking him to telegraph them the lowest cash price for two hundred and twenty tons of forty-pound steel rails. The message was correctly delivered, and in answer thereto Dennis telegraphed to plaintiffs the price to be thirty-seven dollars per ton. This dispatch was delivered in due time, but when delivered it read twenty-seven dollars per ton, the mistake in the message having occurred in transit by reason of atmospheric disturbances. Belying upon the words of the mesr sage as delivered, plaintiffs entered into contracts to buy and sell steel rails, and great damage resulted to them by reason of the mistake of defendant, heretofore stated. To recover this damage the present action was brought.

The facts of the case are largely agreed upon, and in addition, the court made a finding of fact as follows: “'The defendant, Western Union Telegraph Company, was not guilty of gross or any other degree of negligence in the transmission of the message of Dennis to the plaintiffs, nor was the error or mistake in the said dispatch of said Dennis, as the same was delivered to said plaintiffs, due to or caused by the gross or any other…

Sign in to read the full opinion

Create a free account to read the complete opinion text, citation history, and good-law status for this case.