24 Fair empl.prac.cas. 289, 24 Empl. Prac. Dec. P 31,378 Ag 1 Dennis R. Beller v. The Honorable J. William Middendorf, Secretary of the Navy,defendants-Appellees. James Lee Miller v. Donald H. Rumsfeld, Secretary of Defense, Mary Roseann Saal v. J. William Middendorf, Secretary of the United States Navy, in His Officialcapacity

Good Law

632 F.2d 788

United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth CircuitNovember 21, 198077-1354California14,398 words

Opinion

632 F.2d 788 24 Fair Empl.Prac.Cas. 289 , 24 Empl. Prac. Dec. P 31,378 AG 1 Dennis R. BELLER, Plaintiff-Appellant, v. The Honorable J. William MIDDENDORF, Secretary of the Navy, et al.,Defendants-Appellees. James Lee MILLER, Plaintiff-Appellant, v. Donald H. RUMSFELD, Secretary of Defense, et al., Defendants-Appellees. Mary Roseann SAAL, Plaintiff-Appellee, v. J. William MIDDENDORF, Secretary of the United States Navy, in his officialcapacity, Defendant-Appellant. Nos. 77-1354, 77-1671 and 77-2461. United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit. Submitted Nov. 8, 1978. Decided Oct. 23, 1980. Rehearing Denied in No. 77-1354 Nov. 21, 1980. Richard P. Fox, Los Angeles, Cal., for Beller. John Vaisey, San Francisco, Cal., for Miller. James L. Browning, Jr., San Francisco, Cal., on brief; Harland F. Leathers, Washington, D.C., Mary C. Dunlap, San Francisco, Cal., for Middendorf. Appeal from the United States District Court for the Northern District of California. Before BROWNING and KENNEDY, Circuit Judges, and CHRISTENSEN, * District Judge. KENNEDY, Circuit Judge: 1 Although the factual and procedural settings of these three consolidated appeals differ, the broad outlines are similar:…

Sign in to read the full opinion

Create a free account to read the complete opinion text, citation history, and good-law status for this case.

Parties

24 Fair empl.prac.cas. 289, 24 Empl. Prac. Dec. P 31,378 Ag 1 Dennis R. Beller
Plaintiff
The Honorable J. William Middendorf, Secretary of the Navy-. James Lee Miller v. Donald H. Rumsfeld, Secretary of Defense, Mary Roseann Saal v. J. William Middendorf, Secretary of the United States Navy, in His Officialcapacity
Defendant

Cites (117)

632 F.2d 788
427 F. Supp. 192
544 F.2d 865
403 U.S. 388
436 U.S. 604
589 F.2d 669
489 F. Supp. 964
472 F. Supp. 763
312 U.S. 584
424 U.S. 392
592 F.2d 712
369 U.S. 643
586 F.2d 675
337 U.S. 682
571 F.2d 1098
586 F.2d 925
473 F. Supp. 1173
588 F.2d 1281
365 F. Supp. 511
483 F.2d 943
605 F.2d 484
571 F.2d 617
436 U.S. 1
585 F.2d 586
601 F.2d 1102
448 F.2d 222
623 F.2d 605
591 F.2d 849
591 F.2d 852
196 Ct. Cl. 556
506 F.2d 979
481 F.2d 642
422 U.S. 749
415 U.S. 361
490 F.2d 740
449 F. Supp. 207
408 U.S. 564
206 Ct. Cl. 719
566 F.2d 312
56 L. Ed. 2d 83
426 U.S. 312
408 U.S. 593
562 F.2d 1276
429 U.S. 624
427 U.S. 215
426 U.S. 341
424 U.S. 693
581 F.2d 222
537 F.2d 361
596 F.2d 476
562 F.2d 701
474 F. Supp. 848
602 F.2d 7
470 F. Supp. 887
434 U.S. 374
399 U.S. 235
431 U.S. 494
410 U.S. 113
381 U.S. 479
316 U.S. 535
425 U.S. 901
403 F. Supp. 1199
424 N.Y.S.2d 566
600 F.2d 710
544 F.2d 162
539 F.2d 349
50 L. Ed. 2d 585
536 F.2d 1073
485 F. Supp. 470
463 F. Supp. 555
413 U.S. 49
431 U.S. 678
417 U.S. 733
420 U.S. 738
425 U.S. 352
444 U.S. 348
619 F.2d 47
425 U.S. 238
571 F.2d 793
442 U.S. 228
359 U.S. 535
560 F.2d 1384
417 F.2d 1310
598 F.2d 1233
438 U.S. 478
532 F.2d 850
498 F.2d 1146
451 F. Supp. 1313
515 F.2d 926
372 U.S. 609
440 U.S. 957
596 F.2d 435
490 F.2d 700
367 U.S. 886
423 U.S. 147
393 U.S. 199
438 U.S. 531
420 U.S. 636
419 U.S. 498
347 U.S. 497
419 U.S. 379
416 U.S. 696
405 U.S. 208
393 U.S. 268
394 U.S. 618
417 F.2d 1161
63 F.R.D. 399
24 Cal. 3d 458
414 U.S. 632
531 F.2d 1114
413 U.S. 508
435 F.2d 1188
440 F. Supp. 1077
427 U.S. 307
530 F.2d 247
50 L. Ed. 2d 744
367 U.S. 497