Murphy Tugboat Company v. Crowley

658 F.2d 1256 1981-1 Trade Cases 64,000 MURPHY TUGBOAT COMPANY, Plaintiff-Appellant, v. Thomas B. CROWLEY; Shipowners & Merchants Towboat Company, Ltd,; Bay Cities Transportation Company; Harbor Tug & Barge Company; Tug Sea Cloud, Inc.; Tug Sea Fox, Inc.; Tug Sea Horse, Inc.; Tug Sea King, Inc.; Tug Sea Lark, Inc.; Tug Sea Lion, Inc.; Tug Sea Prince, Inc.; Tug Sea Robin, Inc.; Tug Sea Rover, Inc.; Tug Valiant, Inc.; Tug Trojan, Inc.; Tug Atlas, Inc.; Tug Sea Wolf, Inc.; Crowley Launch & Tugboat Company; Cary-Davis Tug & Barge Company and Long Beach Tugboat Company, Inc., Defendants-Appellees. No. 79-4266. United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit. Argued and Submitted Jan. 12, 1981. Decided May 11, 1981. As Amended on Denial of Rehearing and Rehearing En Banc Oct. 15, 1981. Ronald Lovitt, Lovitt & Hannan, Inc., San Francisco, Cal., argued, for plaintiff-appellant; Robert L. Palmer, Martori, Meyer, Henricks & Victor, Phoenix, Ariz., Henry I. Bornstein, San Francisco, Cal., on brief. Kristina M. Hansen, San Francisco, Cal., argued, for defendants-appellees; Richard J. Archer, Sullivan, Jones & Archer, San Francisco, Cal., on brief. Appeal from the…