Hans Bothke v. Fluor Engineers and Constructors, Inc., and W.J. Terry

Bad Law
713 F.2d 1405·52 A.F.T.R.2d (RIA) 5859·1983 U.S. App. LEXIS 31153
United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth CircuitJanuary 24, 198381-5457California6,094 words

Opinion

Opinion

Wright, J.

Bothke, a pro se litigant, appeals from an adverse summary judgment in his suit for damages against an Internal Revenue Service official for claimed constitutional violations in the allegedly wrongful levy of his wages. The district court held that the IRS official was absolutely immune or, alternatively, was protected by qualified immunity because she acted in good faith and within the scope of her authority. This panel affirmed in a memorandum disposition.

The case is now before us on petition for rehearing. Because there seems to be some uncertainty in this circuit over the type of immunity to which IRS agents are entitled, a fuller treatment of the matter is required. We construe Bothke’s petition for rehearing as one for reconsideration, which is granted. The memorandum disposition of January 24, 1983 is withdrawn.

FACTS

Plaintiff-appellant Bothke filed a timely but unusual income tax return for 1977. On several lines he entered asterisks in lieu of dollar amounts. Under the amount to be refunded, he entered $1154.62, an amount corresponding to taxes his employer had withheld from his salary as shown on the W-2 form accompanying the return.

The asterisks were referenced…

Sign in to read the full opinion

Create a free account to read the complete opinion text, citation history, and good-law status for this case.