Stewart

Palmer Cooke & Co. v. Stewart

Good Law
2 Cal. 348
Supreme Court of CaliforniaJuly 15, 1852California99 words

Lead Opinion

Heydenfeldt, J.

The opinion of the Court was delivered by

The power of this Court, to reverse an order of the District Court granting a new trial, is novel, and must be exercised with extreme caution.

In this case, as it is disclosed by the record, the District Court may well have granted or refused a new trial without impeachment of its legal discretion.

The correct doctrine has been heretofore settled by this Court in the case of Drake, et al. v. Palmer, Cook & Co., and upon the authority of that case, the appeal in this is dismissed with costs.