Nunan

Kennedy v. Nunan

Good Law
1877 Cal. LEXIS 110·52 Cal. 326
Supreme Court of CaliforniaJuly 1, 1877No. 5406California1,424 words

Opinion

lead Opinion

Coubt, J.

A trust to receive the rents and profits of lands and pay them over was a familiar trust at common law, (36 lien. Vil!, 1 Cr. Dig. Tit. 12, chap. 1, sec. 12) and gave the cestui que trust an equitable estate in the lands. (4 Kent, margin, p. 310, note 5/1 Cr. Dig. Tit. 12, chap. 2: Story Eq. Jur. secs. 974, 974a, 975; Perry on Trusts, sec. 357, et seq.') And such equitable estate was subject to most of the incidents of a legal estate. In particular, it was descendable, devisable, and alienable.

Under our practice any interest in lands, legal or equitable, of the execution debtor may be sold on execution. (Code of Civil Procedure, secs. 548-688.)

The learned counsel for respondent cited, a number of au *328 thorities in the Court below, holding that the interest of a cestui qyie trust in lands is not leviable when others are also beneficiaries under the trust. (See Freeman on Executions, secs. 187 and 188.) There are many authorities to that effect in the various States, and others holding that no equitable interest, unless it be the interest of a fraudulent grantor, which, as to attaching creditors, is not deemed an equitable but a legal interest, can be reached by execution.…

Sign in to read the full opinion

Create a free account to read the complete opinion text, citation history, and good-law status for this case.