Buttner

Smith v. Buttner

Good Law
1891 Cal. LEXIS 890·90 Cal. 95·27 P. 29
Supreme Court of CaliforniaJune 30, 1891No. 13241California843 words

Opinion

Lead Opinion

Temple, J.

— This appeal is on the judgment roll from a judgment against the plaintiffs on the pleadings.

The plaintiffs are husband and wife, and the action is brought to recover damages for injuries received by the wife. Plaintiffs were occupying a house belonging to defendant as a residence, being his tenants from month to month.

The complaint shows that some time prior to June, 1887, while plaintiffs were in possession as tenants, defendant caused the dwelling-house to be raised some six or seven feet; that plaintiffs continued to reside in the house after it had been raised, and to pay rent to defendant, as before; that after raising the house, and while plaintiffs and their family were living in it, defendant wholly failed and neglected to provide any safe and proper means of entrance to or egress from the house, and “ by reason of the negligence and failure of defendant to provide safe, suitable, or proper means of exit from said house, said plaintiff, Dora Smith, on said thirtieth day of June, 1887, in endeavoring to descend from said house to the ground, for a proper and lawful purpose, while in the exercise of due care and diligence, and without any fault or negligence on her…

Sign in to read the full opinion

Create a free account to read the complete opinion text, citation history, and good-law status for this case.