Obersteller
Obersteller v. Commercial Assurance Co.
Opinion
Lead Opinion
Shabpstein, J.
— This appeal is from a judgment re- • covered by the plaintiff against the defendant in an action upon a policy of insurance, issued by defendant to plaintiff, against loss or damage by fire of certain property, to wit, six hundred dollars on household furniture, useful and ornamental, four hundred dollars on pictures, paintings, and fire-screens, and two hundred dollars on wearing apparel of self and family,—an amount not exceeding twelve hundred dollars. One provision of the policy is, that it shall be void “ in case of any fraud or false swearing by the insured touching any matter relating to the insurance or the subject thereof, whether before or after loss.”
Defendant, in its answer, denied that plaintiff on his part performed all the conditions of said policy, and further answering, alleged, that subsequent to the fire, and prior to the commencement of this action, plaintiff presented to defendant a written statement, subscribed and sworn to, in which he asserted that the damage by the fire to the property insured was $1,845.75, and thereupon demanded payment of the sum of $1,200, the full amount for which said property was insured by defendant. And defendant alleged that…