Phelan

Phelan v. Anderson

Good Law
118 Cal. 504·1897 Cal. LEXIS 805·50 P. 685
Supreme Court of CaliforniaOctober 8, 1897S. F. No. 901California1,097 words

Opinion

Lead Opinion

Gaeotjtte, J.

This is an action of ejectment, brought by the executrix in the interest of the estate of Martin Phelan, deceased. An appeal is prosecuted from the judgment and order denying plaintiff’s motion for a new trial. The case was tried by a jury. Title is admitted in plaintiff, and defendant claims a right of possession under a lease. There are various controverted facts disclosed by the record, but, in view of the verdict of the jury, we are bound to assume those facts in favor of defendant. Defendant’s evidence was to the effect that upon November 1, 1891, plaintiff, by oral agreement, leased to him the land in dispute for the term of five year's, at the yearly rental of six hundred dollars; that under such agreement he entered into possession of the land, and before the bringing of this action had fully paid to plaintiff the rent for the aforesaid five years. This action was begun in March, 1896.

The parol lease for five years under which defendant entered was void, and no rights were fixed by it, but, when an entry is *506 made under such a lease;, all tbe authorities agree that the tenant holds either by tenancy at will or from month to month or from year to year. If the land is…

Sign in to read the full opinion

Create a free account to read the complete opinion text, citation history, and good-law status for this case.