Chierotti

Chierotti v. San Francisco Police Department

Good Law

1942 Cal. LEXIS 351·20 Cal. 2d 895·124 P.2d 51

Supreme Court of CaliforniaApril 2, 1942S. F. No. 16646California92 words

Lead Opinion

Traynor, J.

For the reasons set forth in the opinion in People v. Gonzales and Chierotti, Crim. 4382, this day decided, ant e, p. 165 [ 124 P. 2d 44 ], the order denying the preliminary injunction is affirmed.

Gibson, C. J., Shenk, J., Curtis, J., and Edmonds, J., concurred.

Dissenting Opinion

Carter, J.

I dissent.

For the reasons stated in my dissenting opinion this day filed in the case of People v. Gonzales and Chierotti, Criminal No. 4382, supra, I am of the opinion that the order denying the preliminary injunction should be reversed.

Houser, J., concurred.