Alaska Airlines, Inc. Qwest Commuter Corp. Westair Incorporated v. City of Long Beach Long Beach City Council Evan Braude Wallace Edgerton Jan Hall Thomas J. Clark Ernie Kell James R. Wilson Eunice Sato Ed Tuttle Warren Harwood Ray Grabinski Marc A. Wilder, Long Beach Unified School District Long Beach Hugh, Inc., Defendants-Intervenors v. Pacific Southwest Airlines Aircal Inc. America West Airlines United Air Lines American Airlines, Inc. Ozark Airlines, Inc. Wings West Airlines, Inc. Federal Express Corporation Airserv Delta Air Lines, Inc. Continental Air Lines, Inc., Plaintiffs-Intervenors-Appellees. Alaska Airlines, Inc. Qwest Commuter Corp. Westair Incorporated, and Pacific Southwest Airlines, Inc. Federal Express Corporation Airserv Aircal Inc. United Air Lines American Airlines, Inc. Ozark Airlines, Inc. Wings West Airlines, Inc., AKA American Eagle America West Airlines Delta Air Lines, Inc. Continental Air Lines, Inc., Plaintiffs-Intervenors-Appellees v. City of Long Beach Long Beach City Council, and Its Members

Good Law

92 Daily Journal DAR 368·951 F.2d 977·1992 U.S. App. LEXIS 105

United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth CircuitJanuary 9, 199289-55278California5,495 words

Opinion

951 F.2d 977 ALASKA AIRLINES, INC.; Qwest Commuter Corp.; Westair Incorporated, Plaintiffs-Appellees, v. CITY OF LONG BEACH; Long Beach City Council; Evan Braude; Wallace Edgerton, et al.; Jan Hall; Thomas J. Clark; Ernie Kell; James R. Wilson; Eunice Sato; Ed Tuttle; Warren Harwood; Ray Grabinski; Marc A. Wilder, Defendants-Appellants. LONG BEACH UNIFIED SCHOOL DISTRICT; Long Beach Hugh, Inc., Defendants-Intervenors, v. PACIFIC SOUTHWEST AIRLINES, et al.; Aircal Inc.; America West Airlines; United Air Lines; American Airlines, Inc.; Ozark Airlines, Inc.; Wings West Airlines, Inc.; Federal Express Corporation; Airserv; Delta Air Lines, Inc.; Continental Air Lines, Inc., Plaintiffs-Intervenors-Appellees. ALASKA AIRLINES, INC.; Qwest Commuter Corp.; Westair Incorporated, Plaintiffs-Appellees, and Pacific Southwest Airlines, Inc.; Federal Express Corporation; Airserv; Aircal Inc.; United Air Lines; American Airlines, Inc.; Ozark Airlines, Inc.; Wings West Airlines, Inc., aka American Eagle; America West Airlines; Delta Air Lines, Inc.; Continental Air Lines, Inc., Plaintiffs-Intervenors-Appellees, v. CITY OF LONG BEACH; Long Beach City Council, and its members, Defendants-Appellants.…

Sign in to read the full opinion

Create a free account to read the complete opinion text, citation history, and good-law status for this case.

Parties

Alaska Airlines, Inc. Qwest Commuter Corp. Westair Incorporated
Plaintiff
City of Long Beach Long Beach City Council Evan Braude Wallace Edgerton Jan Hall Thomas J. Clark Ernie Kell James R. Wilson Eunice Sato Ed Tuttle Warren Harwood Ray Grabinski Marc A. Wilder, Long Beach Unified School District Long Beach Hugh, Inc.-Intervenors v. Pacific Southwest Airlines Aircal Inc. America West Airlines United Air Lines American Airlines, Inc. Ozark Airlines, Inc. Wings West Airlines, Inc. Federal Express Corporation Airserv Delta Air Lines, Inc. Continental Air Lines, Inc.-Intervenors-. Alaska Airlines, Inc. Qwest Commuter Corp. Westair Incorporated, and Pacific Southwest Airlines, Inc. Federal Express Corporation Airserv Aircal Inc. United Air Lines American Airlines, Inc. Ozark Airlines, Inc. Wings West Airlines, Inc., AKA American Eagle America West Airlines Delta Air Lines, Inc. Continental Air Lines, Inc.-Intervenors- v. City of Long Beach Long Beach City Council, and Its Members
Defendant

Cites (22)

951 F.2d 977
477 U.S. 1
411 U.S. 624
369 U.S. 84
8 L. Ed. 2d 16
659 F.2d 100
711 F.2d 1006
651 F.2d 1306
865 F.2d 1112
397 U.S. 137
432 U.S. 333
434 U.S. 429
489 U.S. 493
303 U.S. 177
82 L. Ed. 734
427 U.S. 297
402 U.S. 535
347 U.S. 222
442 U.S. 289
111 S. Ct. 2331
631 F.2d 497
942 F.2d 1391