Avila

People v. Avila

Good Law
178 Cal. App. 2d 700·1960 Cal. App. LEXIS 2645·3 Cal. Rptr. 297
Court of Appeal of CaliforniaMarch 8, 1960Crim. No. 6811California1,676 words

Opinion

Lead Opinion

Shinn, J.

Patricia Avila was accused by information of assault upon her daughter Deborah with intent to commit murder and in a separate count of attempted murder of Deborah. She was acquitted upon the latter count and on Count I was found guilty of assault by means of force likely to produce great bodily injury. Her motion for a new trial was denied and probation was granted upon condition that she spend one year in the county jail. She appeals from the judgment and the order.

The points on appeal are (1) the offense of which appellant was convicted is one that is not necessarily included within the offense of assault with intent to commit murder, (2) the child Deborah was shown to be incompetent as a witness and it was error to permit her to testify and (3) “The trial court erred prejudicially in resolving the overwhelming conflicts in testimony against your appellant.”

If by the third point it is intended to urge insufficiency of the evidence to justify the verdict the discussion in appellant’s brief is lamentably inadequate to serve that purpose. The brief does not contain even a pretense of a statement of the evidence. If this were not a criminal case we would not give the point…

Sign in to read the full opinion

Create a free account to read the complete opinion text, citation history, and good-law status for this case.